Vitamin D and Exercise for Knee OA: Key Study Insights

randomized-controlled-trial PMID: 35331018

Vitamin D and Exercise for Knee OA: Key Study Insights

Quick Summary: This study looked at whether intense strength training works better than gentle training for people with knee osteoarthritis, and if adding vitamin D helps those low on the vitamin. It found both training types improved muscle strength about the same, with no extra boost from vitamin D, though the vitamin part had too few people to be sure.

What The Research Found

Researchers tested two types of strength training—high-intensity (pushing hard, like lifting 70-80% of your max weight) and low-intensity (easier, like 40-50% of max)—on people with knee osteoarthritis (OA), a common joint condition causing pain and stiffness. They also checked if vitamin D pills helped those with low vitamin D levels.

Both groups saw similar gains in muscle strength measured by a machine (isokinetic strength), starting around 1.0 units and rising to about 1.1-1.15 units after 12 weeks, with little change by 24 weeks.
High-intensity training edged out low-intensity in one strength test (estimated max lift), but not in overall muscle power, pain relief, or daily function like walking or climbing stairs.
For the 50 people low on vitamin D, taking 1200 IU of vitamin D daily didn't improve strength more than fake pills (placebo). But this part of the study was too small to draw strong conclusions—no "team-up" effect between vitamin D and training.

Overall, both training styles were safe and helpful, suggesting you don't need to go super hard to see benefits.

Study Details

Who was studied: 177 older adults (average age 67.6 years) with knee OA, mostly outpatients at a rehab center. About 50 had vitamin D deficiency (blood levels under 50 nmol/L, meaning their bodies lacked enough of this sunshine vitamin for bone and muscle health).
How long: 12 weeks of strength training sessions, plus follow-up checks at 24 weeks. Vitamin D or placebo was given daily for the full 24 weeks.
What they took: Vitamin D group got 1200 International Units (IU) of vitamin D3 (a form your body absorbs well) in a pill each day. The other group got identical-looking placebo pills with no vitamin D. Training involved weights or machines tailored to each intensity level.

What This Means For You

If you have knee OA and want to build strength to ease pain and move better, this study shows you have options—gentle resistance exercises (like light weights or bands) can work as well as tougher ones, without extra strain. Start with what feels doable, especially if high-intensity sounds intimidating.

For vitamin D: If you're deficient (get tested via bloodwork), 1200 IU daily is a common dose, but it didn't supercharge training here. Still, vitamin D supports bones and muscles overall—talk to your doctor about supplements if you get little sun or eat few fatty fish. Combine any training with doc-approved plans to avoid injury. Bottom line: Exercise helps knee OA symptoms regardless of intensity, and vitamin D might play a supporting role, but more research is needed.

Study Limitations

The vitamin D test only included 50 people, so it couldn't spot small benefits—results might change with a bigger group.
Training lasted just 12 weeks, which may not show long-term effects on pain or function.
Participants were mostly older adults with knee issues, so findings might not apply to younger folks or other joint problems.
Pain and function were self-reported via surveys, which can vary by person and introduce some bias.
No info on vitamin D levels for everyone, so we don't know if it helps those with normal levels.

Key Findings

The study found that high-intensity resistance training (70-80% 1-RM) did not significantly improve isokinetic muscle strength (primary outcome), knee pain, or physical functioning compared to low-intensity RT (40-50% 1-RM) in patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA). However, high-intensity RT showed a small advantage in estimated 1-RM (a secondary measure of muscle strength). In a subgroup of 50 vitamin D-deficient patients, adding 1200 IU/day vitamin D3 to RT did not enhance isokinetic strength compared to placebo over 24 weeks. The authors noted the vitamin D analysis was underpowered, limiting conclusions about its efficacy.

Study Design

This was a 12-week randomized controlled trial with a 24-week follow-up, conducted at an outpatient rehabilitation center. 177 participants (mean age: 67.6 ± 5.8 years) with knee OA were randomized into high-intensity or low-intensity RT groups. A subgroup of 50 vitamin D-deficient participants (serum 25(OH)D <50 nmol/L) received either vitamin D3 (1200 IU/day) or placebo.

Dosage & Administration

Vitamin D3 was administered orally at 1200 International Units (IU) per day for 24 weeks. Placebo capsules were identical in appearance. Supplementation began alongside RT interventions (high- or low-intensity), which lasted 12 weeks.

Results & Efficacy

Isokinetic muscle strength (Nm/kg):
High-intensity group: 0.98 ± 0.40 (baseline), 1.11 ± 0.40 (post-12 weeks), 1.09 ± 0.42 (post-24 weeks).
Low-intensity group: 1.02 ± 0.41 (baseline), 1.15 ± 0.42 (post-12 weeks), 1.12 ± 0.40 (post-24 weeks).
No significant differences between groups at any timepoint (p-values unspecified).
Estimated 1-RM: High-intensity RT showed greater improvements than low-intensity (p < 0.05).
Vitamin D subgroup: No differences in isokinetic strength between vitamin D and placebo groups (p-values unspecified).
Secondary outcomes (pain, physical functioning): No significant between-group differences reported.

Limitations

Underpowered vitamin D analysis: Only 50 participants were vitamin D-deficient, limiting the ability to detect meaningful effects.
Short RT duration: The 12-week intervention may be insufficient to observe long-term strength or clinical benefits.
Homogeneous sample: Participants were older adults (mean age 67.6) with knee OA; findings may not generalize to younger populations or other joint conditions.
Self-reported outcomes: Pain and physical functioning were assessed via questionnaires, which may introduce bias.
No baseline vitamin D levels reported for the full cohort: Subgroup analysis was restricted to deficient individuals, but effects in non-deficient patients remain unclear.

Clinical Relevance

For patients with knee OA, both high- and low-intensity RT appear safe and similarly effective for improving isokinetic muscle strength and symptoms. While high-intensity RT improved 1-RM (a measure of maximal strength), this did not translate to better pain or functional outcomes. Vitamin D supplementation (1200 IU/day) did not enhance RT benefits in deficient individuals, but the small subgroup sample size prevents definitive conclusions. Clinicians should consider individual tolerance and preferences when prescribing RT intensity and prioritize larger trials to confirm vitamin D’s role in OA management. Patients should not assume vitamin D supplementation will amplify strength gains without further evidence.

Word count: 398